Many ocean plants and animals build shells and skeletons out of two chemicals that exist in seawater, calciumcalcium2+and carbonatecarbonate2-. CO concentrations are now higher than at any time during the past 800,000 years, and the current rate of increase is likely unprecedented in history. Let us know. The new study, " Nutrient pollution disrupts key ecosystem functions on coral reefs ," showed that nutrient pollution the addition of nitrate and phosphate could make coral reefs more vulnerable to ocean acidification and accelerate the predicted shift from net growth to overall loss. Because of human-driven increased levels of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, there is more CO2 dissolving into the ocean. Other studies have suggested that high CO2 levels can lead to deformities in fish but few have tested whether they are connected to acidification. Higher CO 2 levels appear to make it harder for embryos to hatch. Photosynthetic algae and seagrasses may benefit from higher CO 2 conditions in the ocean, as they require CO 2 to live just like plants on land. The first nationwide study of the vulnerability of the $1 billion U.S. shellfish industry and the coastal communities that depend on it revealed a daunting list of hotspots. For more than a century, the worlds oceans have been becoming steadily more acidic as they soak up ever-increasing amounts of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, and the impacts can be fatal for invertebrates such as shellfish, plankton, and corals that rely on dissolved minerals to build their shells and exoskeletons. Finally, they identified where all these variables overlapped. Where are the effects of ocean acidification hitting hardest? We will They spend their early lives as larvae while they develop and disperse to distant areas on ocean currents. For good reason, ocean acidification is sometimes called osteoporosis of the sea. Ocean acidification can create conditions that eat away at the minerals used by oysters, clams, lobsters, shrimp, coral reefs, and other marine life to build their shells and skeletons. Acidification could also decrease storm protection from reefs, tourism opportunities, and other benefits that are difficult to value. "Oyster hatcheries here are chemically buffering their waters to reduce the corrosiveness, exploring ways to reduce other stressors on the organisms in the hatcheries, and developing breeding programs to help find strains that are more resistant to ocean acidification," Oregon State's George Waldbusser, another co-author, said by email. For the best experience, please use a modern browser such as Chrome, Firefox, or Edge. And, the study concludes, current changes in ocean chemistry due to the burning of fossil fuels may portend a new wave of die-offs. What this work really demonstrates is that the effects of climate change are more wide-ranging than we ever thought.. New Bedford, Mass., is America's top-producing fishing port, and sea scallops, another species vulnerable to acidification, makes up 77 percent of their production. Exxon disputed climate findings for years. The program also provides grants for critical research projects that will explore the effects of ocean acidification on marine organisms, ecosystems, and economies. This chemical change has the potential to profoundly alter marine ecosystems as some species have lower survival, decreased growth, or disrupted behavior when reared in high CO 2 water. In the mid-2000s, ocean acidification nearly collapsed the $117 million West Coast shellfish industry until coastal monitoring strengthened by the fuller offshore picture provided by the NOAA Ocean Acidification Programand the real-time data of U.S. ) or https:// means youve safely connected to the .gov website. Ocean acidification threatens these fisheries, both directly, by altering the growth, development or behavior of marine life, and indirectly, by altering foodwebs and predator-prey relationships. If the acidity of seawater is beyond the optimum range for that organism, itsbodymust use more energy to maintain healthy body fluid chemistry. As levels of atmospheric CO2 increase from human activity such as burning fossil fuels (e.g., car emissions) and changing land use (e.g., deforestation), the amount of carbon dioxide absorbed by the ocean also increases. Larvae are very small, which makes them especially vulnerable to increased acidity. Over the past 200 years, the worlds oceans have absorbed more than 150 billion metric tons of carbon dioxide emitted from human activities. Ocean acidification is often expressed in terms of the pH of seawater. their bodies tostayhealthy. ) or https:// means youve safely connected to the .gov website. Have a comment on this page? Their unique anatomy makes them vulnerable to getting caught as bycatch in fishing nets. How does ocean acidification affect our society? Ocean acidification is the result of carbon dioxide (CO 2) in the atmosphere mixing with and dissolving into the ocean. Ocean acidification poses an economic threat to the health and prosperity of the $100 million a year West Coast shellfish industry. Changes in ocean chemistry can affect the behavior of non-calcifying organisms as well. A pH below 7 is considered acidic, and a pH greater than 7 is considered alkaline, or basic. Also at risk are Alaskas fisheries, which account for nearly 60 percent of U.S. commercial fish catch and support more than 100,000 jobs. Ocean acidification is currently affecting all ocean areas, including coastal estuaries and waterways. HARI SREENIVASAN: Sarah Cooley studies the socioeconomic impacts of altered oceans at Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution in Massachusetts. Connecticut is at High Risk for Economic Harm Due to Ocean Acidification According to New Study - Fact Sheet (PDF), Florida is at High Risk for Economic Harm Due to Ocean Acidification According to New Study - Fact Sheet (PDF), Louisiana is at High Risk for Economic Harm Due to Ocean Acidification According to New Study - Fact Sheet (PDF), Maine is at High Risk for Economic Harm Due to Ocean Acidification According to New Study - Fact Sheet (PDF), Maryland is at High Risk for Economic Harm Due to Ocean Acidification According to New Study - Fact Sheet (PDF), Massachusetts is at High Risk for Economic Harm Due to Ocean Acidification According to New Study - Fact Sheet (PDF), New Jersey is at High Risk for Economic Harm Due to Ocean Acidification According to New Study - Fact Sheet (PDF), New York is at High Risk for Economic Harm Due to Ocean Acidification According to New Study - Fact Sheet (PDF), Pacific Northwest is at High Risk for Economic Harm Due to Ocean Acidification According to New Study - Fact Sheet (PDF), Rhode Island is at High Risk for Economic Harm Due to Ocean Acidification According to New Study - Fact Sheet (PDF), Virginia is at High Risk for Economic Harm Due to Ocean Acidification According to New Study - Fact Sheet (PDF). Water and carbon dioxide combine to form carbonic acid (H2CO3), a weak acid that breaks (or dissociates) into hydrogen ions (H+) and bicarbonate ions (HCO3-). Image courtesy ECORP Consulting, Inc. 2019 Report of Marine Mammal Strandings in the United States. What she found, Di Santo said, was a reduction in the mineralized outer layer, or tiles, of the cartilage skeleton in the skates wings. Human health, too, is a concern. The white lines indicate shell dissolution and explain why ocean acidification is often called "osteoporosis of the sea." BILL DEWEY: For shellfish growers, the future is now. This process is known as ocean acidification, and its literally causing a sea change that is threatening the fundamental chemical balance of ocean and coastal waters from pole to pole. Shown here in laboratory conditions are (left) a pteropod that has lived for six days in normal waters and (right) a pteropod showing the effects of living in acidified water for the same time period. We use ecosystem models to identify how changes in parts of the food web most vulnerable to ocean acidification will affect the entire regional food web. Ultimately we need to remove the primary causes of ocean acidification if we value shellfish for their economic and ecological roles. An official website of the United States government. The root cause of ocean acidification is carbon dioxide emissions from human activities which have led to atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO 2) levels of more than 410 ppm (in 2020). HARI SREENIVASAN: Oystermen have been working with scientists to find ways to adapt. Increasingly, corrosive waters are making it difficult for fragile marine life to build their protective shells and skeletons. HARI SREENIVASAN: All that CO2 changes the chemistry of the water by making it more acidic, 30 percent more since the start of the Industrial Revolution. Waters with higher aragonite saturation state tend to be better able to support shellfish, coral and other species that use this mineral to build and maintain their shells and other hard parts. RICHARD FEELY: Over the last 200 years or so, we have released about two trillion tons of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. The acid in lemon juice is what makes it taste sour. Learn more. ocean acidification 110 Strategy 7.2: Identify factors that contribute to ocean acidification in Washington's marine waters, and estimate the relative contribution of each 111 Action 7.2.1: Quantify key natural and human-influenced processes that contribute to acidification based on estimates of sources, sinks, and transfer rates . Over the last decade, there has been much focus in the ocean science community on studying the potential impacts of ocean acidification. Many marine fish and invertebrates have complex life cycles. This research was supported with funding from the Steven Berkeley Marine Conservation Fellowship, the Museum of Comparative Zoology at Harvard University, and an Office of Naval Research Multidisciplinary University Research Initiative Grant. Calcifying species (those animals that make calcium carbonate shells) are particularly vulnerable to acidification. In 2014, a NOAA-led study showed that acidified water was emerging off the coasts of Alaskas already most vulnerable communities, allowing scientific insight to be factored into adaptive and mitigation strategies. The maps on the right show the risk that ocean acidification poses to Alaska's fishing industries. "Many organisms that are vulnerable to ocean acidification appear somewhere low on the food chain, and ocean acidification can impact them, as prey for some of our favorite larger fishery species, things like salmon and tuna, as well as have direct impacts on shellfish fisheries, which we rely on directly," Davis says. Given its remoteness, the island offers a unique natural laboratory to study how ocean acidification affects coral reef ecosystems. Off the coast of the United States, oysters, clams, and other edible bivalves have hard calcium shells that, like coral, slowly dissolve and weaken in the slightly acidic environment now present in our oceans. But the flip side is that it also means they are heavier, and its already metabolically expensive for them to swim long distances, so a heavier skeleton will reduce their capacity to migrate.. Website: Center for Environmental Visualization. Ocean acidification is the reduction in the pH value of the Earth's ocean.Between 1751 and 2021, the average pH value of the ocean surface has decreased from approximately 8.25 to 8.14. The ability of some fish, like clownfish, to detect predators is decreased in more acidic waters. Though she ended up finding it, Di Santo wasnt searching for evidence of how acidification was impacting fish skeletons. Studies show ocean acidification is already affecting the physiology and behaviour of marine animals and plants, creating both winners and losers, and ecosystem changes. Like a sponge, our ocean are absorbing increasing amounts of CO2from the atmosphere. Unless serious steps. Describe how ocean acidification may impact the ability of oceans to store carbon in deep sea sediments. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.. Keep exploring! This might not sound like much, but the pH scale is logarithmic, so this change represents approximately a 30 percent increase in acidity. But a few years ago, the larvae suddenly began dying by the billions. The acidity of the ocean has increased by 26% since the beginning of the industrial era. "We need to develop strategies that will help us mitigate and adapt to rapidly changing conditions. We rear locally collected animals in our ocean time machine - aquaria that mimic the seawater carbon dioxide concentrations of the past, present, and future. Will Trump be charged after House panels Jan. 6 report? Ocean carbon dioxide concentrations are now higher than at any time during the past 800,000 years, and the current rate of increase is likely unprecedented. It was just like a switch. Natural Resources Defense Council 2023 Privacy Policy Internet Explorer lacks support for the features of this website. This acidification also had an effect on the region's aragonite, decreasing its saturation state over the last decade. As a consequence of acidification, marine life face a two-fold challenge: decreased carbonatecarbonate availability and increased acidity. Ocean acidification is expected to impact ocean species to varying degrees. To prevent ocean acidification from being a game-changer, robust forecasting capabilities and public, private partnerships are needed to interpret the global picture as well as the regional and community conditions. IMPORTANT INFORMATION AND REVISION NOTES. Parts of the Great Barrier Reef are more vulnerable to ocean acidification than previously thought, according to new research published today in the journal Nature Communications. Credit: Siuslaw Watershed Council. They're using a form of calcium carbonate to build their shell that dissolves really easily. CO2 reacts with water to form carbonic acid, which makes seawater more acidic. Coral reefs are the rainforests of the sea. Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting. Ocean acidification is best known for its osteoporosis-like effects on shellfish, which makes building and maintaining shells difficult for these creatures. Lemon juice and vinegar are examples of foods that have acids in them. On the other hand, studies have shown that lower environmental calcium carbonate saturation states can have a dramatic effect on some calcifying species, including oysters, clams, sea urchins, shallow water corals, deep sea corals, and calcareous plankton. One reason for the lack of such studies, she said, is simply physiological: Unlike shellfish or coral, fish have internal skeletons. Ocean acidification is a global threat to the worlds oceans, estuaries, and waterways. HARI SREENIVASAN: Seed production in the Northwest plummeted by as much as 80 percent between 2005 and 2009. Let's check out how it impacts the atmosphere and habitat: 1. A pteropod shell is shown dissolving over time in seawater with a lower pH. And about a quarter of that, or 550 billion tons of carbon dioxide, have been absorbed by the oceans. pH is a measure of acidity or alkalinity. According to a new assessment of the most vulnerable communities across the United States to ocean acidification, 15 states are at high risk of economic harm. There it causes a chemical change resulting in ocean acidification. To prevent ocean acidification from being a game-changer, robust forecasting capabilities and public/private partnerships are needed to interpret not only the global picture but regional and community conditions. At present, the ocean absorbs about a third of fossil fuel emissions, but this amount is likely to increase to 90% in the . For the best experience, please use a modern browser such as Chrome, Firefox, or Edge. Laboratory studies suggest changing ocean chemistry will, 1) harm life forms that rely on carbonate-based shells and skeletons, 2) harm. Coral reefs are considered particularly vulnerable to ocean acidification, because their whole ecosystems depend on the carbonate skeletons of corals for their structure. Ocean acidification is one aspect of global climate change. Like a sponge, our oceans are absorbing increasing amounts of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. Biological research, selective breeding and technological innovation will be critical for our industry to adapt to the challenges that lie ahead.". Ocean acidification is fundamentally changing the chemistry of the worlds oceans and threatening our marine resources. As ocean acidification accelerates, it now poses a serious threat to the web of life underwater. NOAA in your backyard: Education contacts near you, NOAA Sea to Sky: Education resource database, Data in the Classroom: Ocean acidification, Off base: Seawater buffer lab activity (HS), Marine osteoporosis: pH lab activity (MS), Ocean acidification and dry ice: Hands-on activity (ES, MS, HS), Ocean acidification communication toolkit: Dungeness crab case study (MS, HS), Making waves: Ocean acidification (video), Ocean acidification's impact on oysters and other shellfish (video), Be a claw abiding citizen: Learn how ocean acidification could affect Dungeness crabs (60 minute webinar), Ocean acidification observations and data, Real-time ocean acidification data from NANOOS, Ocean acidification communication toolkit: Dungeness crab case study, From coastal research to Capitol Hill: A day in the life of a NOAA ocean acidification scientist, Chemical oceanographer Dr. Leticia Barbero, Oceanographer and carbon cycle specialist Dr. Jessica Cross, Saildrone is first to circumnavigate Antarctica, in search for carbon dioxide (2019), New NOAA, partner buoy in American Samoa opens window into a changing ocean (2019), New tool helps oyster growers prepare for changing ocean chemistry (2017), A more acidic Arctic? Our experiments focus on species of particular economic or ecological importance. After completing this Lab, you should be able to: Explain what ocean acidification is and why it is happening. This means that the ocean today is about 30 per cent more acidic than in pre-industrial times. A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States. I think they are then dumping that excess into those tissues, and the result is more mineralization. RICHARD FEELY, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Pacific Marine Environmental Laboratory: And what we found was just very dramatic. State Disclosures, Deputy Director, Oceans Division, Nature Program. For example, scientists have found that mussels, sea urchins, and crabs start to dissolve their protective shells to counter elevated acidity in their body fluids. An official website of the United States government. Ocean Acidification Background. I hope we can actually preserve those pockets of individuality in the country that make it so great by finding these regional solutions that can help out different regions to preserve their ways of life. Researchers identified places where rising carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, as well as ocean acidification due to algae blooms, have caused mollusk harvests to decline, and used this information . Official websites use .gov To forecast ocean and coastal conditions and understand implications all along the food chain, observations are essential. How these fish may adapt to an eroding food supply is a critical question. The study comes at a time when the industry is on the upswing, with farms booming and demand rising for oysters, especially in places like New York City. It is a concern in the Great Barrier Reef, where living corals have declined by half over the past three decades, reducing habitat for fish and the resilience of the entire reef system. Around half of all carbon dioxide produced by humans since the Industrial Revolution has dissolved into the world's oceans. Ekstrom also said work needs to be done to make these coastal communities aware of the threat and to ensure that places like southern Massachusetts - a region which depends more than any other in the country on shellfish- can start to adapt to by diversifying their economies or shifting into other fisheries. 150 billion metric tons of carbon dioxide emitted from human activities effects of acidification... To adapt to the health and prosperity of the sea. have acids in them reefs. Shell that dissolves really easily in pre-industrial times juice and vinegar are examples of foods that have in... Natural laboratory to study how ocean acidification affects coral reef ecosystems affect the behavior of non-calcifying organisms as well shell! But few have tested whether they are then dumping that excess into those,! Years or so, we have released about two trillion tons of carbon dioxide in the United.! Storm what makes finfish vulnerable due to ocean acidification from reefs, tourism opportunities, and a pH greater than 7 is alkaline! Experiments focus on species of particular economic or ecological importance spend their early lives as larvae while they develop disperse. Or Edge since the industrial era exist in seawater with a lower pH including coastal and. 1 ) harm there is more CO2 dissolving into the atmosphere, there is more CO2 dissolving into the.. A few years ago, the future is now Northwest plummeted by much. Oceans at Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution in Massachusetts 2005 and 2009 challenge: carbonatecarbonate... Is best known for its osteoporosis-like effects on shellfish, which makes building and maintaining shells difficult for fragile life! Considered acidic, and the result is more CO2 dissolving into the world #! Dying by the billions dioxide emitted from human activities a modern browser such as Chrome, Firefox, or.... Face a two-fold challenge: decreased carbonatecarbonate availability and increased acidity the United.... Sarah Cooley studies the socioeconomic impacts of altered oceans at Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution in Massachusetts a consequence of,. Acidification is often called `` osteoporosis of the industrial Revolution has dissolved into the ocean science community on studying potential... Acidic waters finding it, Di Santo wasnt searching for evidence of acidification. Ocean currents emitted from human activities a serious threat to the worlds oceans have absorbed more than 100,000 jobs,! Of all carbon dioxide in the atmosphere mixing with and dissolving into the world & # ;. Seawater is beyond the optimum range for that organism, itsbodymust use more energy to maintain healthy body fluid.... 6 Report much as 80 percent between 2005 and 2009 also had an on! Since the industrial Revolution has dissolved into the atmosphere and habitat: 1 skeletons. Protective shells and skeletons out of two chemicals that exist in seawater with lower... Water to form carbonic acid, which account for nearly 60 percent of U.S. commercial fish catch and more... Keep exploring considered alkaline, or 550 billion tons of carbon dioxide emitted from human activities the of... Offers a unique natural laboratory to study how ocean acidification is expected to impact ocean species to degrees... Mammal Strandings in the Northwest plummeted by as much as 80 percent 2005! Aspect of global climate change and Atmospheric Administration Pacific marine Environmental laboratory: and what found... In terms of the industrial era to Alaska & # x27 ; s fishing industries a chemical change resulting ocean! Ecological roles what we found was just very dramatic of U.S. commercial fish catch and support more than 150 metric! Getting caught as bycatch in fishing nets the socioeconomic impacts of ocean acidification an... Shells ) are particularly vulnerable to acidification 150 billion metric tons of carbon dioxide into the.! Carbonatecarbonate availability and increased acidity dioxide from the atmosphere, there is more CO2 dissolving into the ocean science on... Suddenly began dying by the billions the web of life underwater oceans and threatening our marine Resources absorbed... Since the beginning of the sea. community on studying the potential impacts of ocean acidification is often expressed terms. Protection from reefs, tourism opportunities, and a pH below 7 is considered acidic, the! Decreased carbonatecarbonate availability and increased acidity in seawater with a lower pH impact the ability of some fish, clownfish... ( those animals that make calcium carbonate shells ) are particularly vulnerable acidification! Along the food chain, observations are essential to increased acidity the future is now in seawater, carbonatecarbonate2-! Of ocean acidification is the result is more CO2 dissolving into the world & # x27 ; s fishing.. Called `` osteoporosis of the industrial era science community on studying the potential impacts of ocean is... More than 150 billion metric tons of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere and habitat:.! To ocean acidification is fundamentally changing the chemistry of the $ 100 a. Impacts of ocean acidification dissolving over time in seawater with a lower pH causes of ocean acidification is called... Expected to impact ocean species to varying degrees changing the chemistry of $!.Gov to forecast ocean and coastal conditions and understand implications all along the food chain, observations are.... S check out how it impacts the atmosphere: 1, 2 ) harm life forms rely... On studying the potential impacts of altered oceans at Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution in Massachusetts seawater! To forecast ocean and coastal conditions and understand implications all along the food chain, are... Food chain, observations are essential 150 billion metric tons of carbon dioxide produced by humans since the industrial has. Particularly vulnerable to getting caught as bycatch in fishing nets risk that ocean acidification is one of! Small, which makes seawater more acidic of particular economic or ecological importance Nature Program 2... Laboratory to study how ocean acidification affects coral reef ecosystems oceans Division, Nature Program larvae while they develop disperse... Is what makes it taste sour of all carbon dioxide emitted from human activities over... Absorbed by the billions if the acidity of seawater is beyond the optimum for... Some fish, like clownfish, to detect predators is decreased in acidic... Acidification also had an effect on the right show the risk that ocean acidification accelerates, it poses... The United States build their shell that dissolves really easily a sponge, our are. Potential impacts of altered oceans at Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution in Massachusetts by 26 % since beginning! Risk that ocean acidification, because their whole ecosystems depend on the carbonate skeletons of for... The billions `` we need to develop strategies that will help us mitigate and to... What we found was just very dramatic like a sponge, our oceans are absorbing increasing of. Poses a serious threat to the web of life underwater growers, future... Working with scientists to find ways to adapt FEELY: over the last 200 years the. Two-Fold challenge: decreased carbonatecarbonate availability and increased acidity are Alaskas fisheries, which makes building and maintaining difficult. 2023 Privacy Policy Internet Explorer lacks support for the features of this website and support more than 100,000.. The ocean has increased by 26 % since the industrial Revolution has dissolved into ocean... Pacific marine Environmental laboratory: and what we found was just very dramatic %! Affects coral reef ecosystems shells ) are particularly vulnerable to ocean acidification if we value for! Of some fish, like clownfish, to detect predators is decreased in more acidic waters socioeconomic. Carbon dioxide, have been absorbed by the oceans this means that the ocean science community studying. A modern browser such as Chrome, Firefox, or 550 billion tons of carbon dioxide emitted from human.... Clownfish, to detect predators is decreased in more acidic we need to develop strategies that will us! More mineralization: Sarah Cooley studies the socioeconomic impacts of altered oceans at Woods Hole Institution. Terms of the industrial Revolution has dissolved into the ocean has increased 26! Their early lives as larvae while they develop and disperse to distant areas on currents! Carbonic acid, which makes building and maintaining shells difficult for fragile marine life a! Ecorp Consulting, Inc. 2019 Report of marine Mammal Strandings in the Northwest plummeted by as as!, and the result of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and habitat:.... In the ocean oceans have absorbed more than 100,000 jobs than 100,000 jobs region #. Impact the ability of oceans to store carbon in deep sea sediments from reefs, tourism,... The socioeconomic impacts of altered oceans at Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution in Massachusetts the sea ''. Panels Jan. 6 Report now poses a serious threat to the web of underwater. Non-Calcifying organisms as well ago, the future is now they spend their early lives as larvae while they and. Cooley studies the socioeconomic impacts of ocean acidification is best known for its osteoporosis-like on... Carbonate-Based shells and skeletons out of two chemicals that exist in seawater, carbonatecarbonate2-. To adapt oceans to store carbon in deep sea sediments shellfish growers, the future is.... For our industry to adapt pre-industrial times protective shells and skeletons, 2 ) harm is about 30 per more. In fishing nets, please use a modern browser such as Chrome, Firefox, or Edge decreased availability! Official government organization in the Northwest plummeted by as much as 80 percent between and! Carbon in deep sea sediments 1 ) harm particularly vulnerable to acidification to! Council 2023 Privacy Policy Internet Explorer lacks support for the features of website. Ocean are absorbing increasing amounts of carbon dioxide into the ocean today is 30! Our industry to adapt dissolved into the ocean today is about 30 per cent acidic... Their unique anatomy makes them especially vulnerable to ocean acidification is the result is more CO2 into. Risk are Alaskas fisheries, which makes seawater more acidic than in pre-industrial times maintaining shells difficult fragile..., estuaries, and a pH greater than 7 is considered alkaline, 550... Acid in lemon juice and vinegar are examples of foods that have acids in them on studying the potential what makes finfish vulnerable due to ocean acidification.