Refer to the following information. Sub-rule 2: Questions of legal right and liability should generally be decided by application of the law and not the exercise of the discretion. In Chapters 11 and 12, having explained and defended his principles, Bingham applies them with excoriating effect to Terrorism and the Rule of Law (Chapter 11) and The Rule of Law and the Sovereignty of Parliament (Chapter 12). As Lord Hewart said, It is not necessary to be a horticulturist to realize that if a tree bears bad fruit, the more vigorously it delivers, the greater the calamity harvest will be. In short, public servants have a duty to apply established rules, but cannot invent new rules of their own. For many people, going online to take classes seems like a convenient and efficient way to get an education. The principles encompassed within the Petition of Rights include: The right of Habeas Corpusis an essential feature of the rule of law, and is not explicitly mentioned in the Magna Carta but subject to much future legislation. These are the modern definitions bought up by the scholars. Disappointingly for the then senior law lord, "the legal correspondents of the leading newspapers . By adhering to these 8 principles, especially the fifth, which ensure adequate protection of fundamental human rights, we avoid the dilemma identified by Professor Joseph Raz in his 1979 book The Authority of Law. The rule of law is meant to enable the law to promote social good. Web* Bei Fragen einfach anrufen oder schreiben: +49 (0)176 248 87 424. did picasso and matisse paint a fence; hunter's green tampa hoa rules; what's the crime rate in springfield? \textbf{Comparative Balance Sheets}\\ westchester general hospital ceo. B. 2. The Rule of Law has a correct function in ensuring that public authorities do not exceed their But is online learning as effective as face-to-face learning? The Petition of Rights extended the rule of law and due process to encompass some implied terms of the Magna Carta. It features illuminating scrutiny of US extraordinary rendition (basically used to kidnap suspects and torture them for information) and UK surveillance (more than 4 million CCTV cameras and the largest DNA database in the world). The Divisional Court held that the SFO's decision to stop the investigation was based upon threats and incompatible with the rule of law. INCLUDING THIS SITE. Tom Bingham Allen Lane; Hardback (February 2010); 20 ISBN 9781846140907 There is a general, though not universal, feeling that the rule of law is a Good Thing. $$ The idea of the rule of law as the foundation of modern states and civilisations has recently become even more talismanic than that of democracy, but what does it actually consist of? The Rule of Law was chosen as a book of the year by Chris Patten (in the By analysing the UK constitution it becomes clear that there are some key principles which shape the . Although procedures were delineated, questions remained. The law should apply equally to all, except where objective differences justify differentiation 4. You should be aware of recent legal issues, which bring into question the applicability of Dicey's (and other authors) conception of the rule of law. Laws themselves do not rule, since ruling requires action and laws cannot act. \text{Income taxes payable }&\underline{\text{\hspace{12pt}1,400}}&\underline{\text{\hspace{12pt}2,600}}\\ The law must afford adequate protection of fundamental human rights, including, the right to respect for private and family life, freedom of thought, conscience and religion, Access to our library of course-specific study resources, Up to 40 questions to ask our expert tutors, Unlimited access to our textbook solutions and explanations. \text{Cost of goods sold}&\text{}&\underline{\text{\hspace{5pt}314,200}}\\ (select all that apply) Group of answer choices In text citations with two or more authors used inside parentheses In the title of a manuscript, According to Grove and Gray (2019), which of the following statements are important when considering the significance and relevance of a study's problem and purpose ? 2 Questions of legal right and liability should ordinarily be resolved by application of the law and not the exercise of discretion. As Aristotle explained in the fourth century BC, 'the rule of law is to be preferred to that of any individual'. It was a system perceived as biased, unfair and unjust. Registered office: Creative Tower, Fujairah, PO Box 4422, UAE. . Course Hero is not sponsored or endorsed by any college or university. While some scholars have suggested that it should be 'content-free' dealing only with the form of law and procedural matters, others have suggested that it should be 'content-full' and should contain substantive elements of laws which should be required to comply with fundamental rights. \text{Retained earnings}&\underline{\text{\hspace{12pt}35,600}}&\underline{\text{\hspace{17pt}8,400}}\\ Sub-rule 8: The state must comply with the obligations of international law which whether deriving from treaty or international custom and practice governs the conduct of nations. *You can also browse our support articles here >, Anti-Terrorism, Crime and Security Act 2001, Asylum and Immigration [Treatment of Claimants] Act 2004, R (on the application of Al Rawi and others) v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs and another, R (Corner House Research) v Director of the Serious Fraud Office. $$ The heart of the book is gripping, however, as it elaborates on the eight principles using real cases ranging from the abolition of slavery in Britain following the 1772 James Somerset case to modern-day discrimination against non-citizens in the 2004 Belmarsh prisoners case. Its simple language, engaging case studies, and a sprinkling of humour make it a compelling read for different audiences, including high school students considering studying Law at university. EVERYTHING IS PERSONAL. 3. the existing constitutional principle of the rule. of law or the LCs existing constitutional role in. The rule of law by Tom Bingham clearly and concisely unpacks an elusive concept that has become a sort of stock phrase in the legal profession. The Rule of Law. $$. [] There is no more effective practical safeguard against arbitrary and unreasonable governments than to require that the legal principles that officials would impose on a minority be universally applied. It requires, as well, measures to ensure adherence to the principles of supremacy of law, equality before the law, accountability to the Among Blacks, $52 \%$ are Male and $48 \%$ Female, and among Hispanic/Latino/Other, $58 \%$ are Male and $42 \%$ are Female. He was Lord Chief Justice of England and Wales, and Master of the Rolls, and Senior Law Lord. \textbf{CRUZ, INC.}\\ According to U.S. Census data, $68 \%$ of the civilian U.S. labor force self-identifies as White, $11 \%$ as Black, and the remaining $21 \%$ as Hispanic/Latino or Other. He believed that this would open a Pandora`s box, that is, arbitrariness, which is the antithesis of the rule of law. Webthe following statements by law lords: 5 Lord Bingham referred to the thin and thick definitions: Bingham, Tom, The Rule of Law, Allen Lane, 2010, pp6667 6 The significance of the rule of law goes beyond judicial review. \text{Net income}&\text{}&\underline{\underline{\text{\$\hspace{7pt}30,000}}}\\ Perhaps both arguments are valid as they are both addressing the issue of the rule of law from different angles. In this short concise book, Tom Bingham first examines the historical origins of the rule -- such as the Magna Carta 1215, Habeas corpus, Petition of Right 1628, Sir Matthew Hale's resolutions and the Universal Declaration of . Even if the principles of the Rule of Law are purely formal in their application, we don't just value them for formalistic reasons. I n November 2006, Lord Bingham delivered an academic paper called The Rule of Law. The scope of the rule of law remained vaguely defined during this period. All Collumns in a table should be labeled. b. Bingham accredits the "currency" of the rule of law to A.V. Lord Bingham in 2010 identified eight sub-rules to the ROL which has formed criteria to describe what ROL is in the twenty-first century. To summarize the above, U.S. Justice Jackson stated in 1949: I consider it a salutary doctrine that cities, states, and the federal government must exercise their powers not to discriminate among residents except in the case of reasonable differentiation reasonably connected with the purpose of the regulation. \text{Gross profit}&\text{}&\text{174,000}\\ ISBN: 9780141034539. Their appeals to the Adjudicator and IAT were also rejected. Lord Bingham argues that there are eight principles which should be used to define the meaning of the rule of law: 1 The law must be accessible, intelligible, clear and predictable. Its central focus is to constrain the . "Rule of Law" is a term that is frequently unthinkingly used in contemporary political discourse, and which in fact represents different things to different users: when some on the . \text{Cash}&\text{\$\hspace{5pt}94,800}&\text{\$\hspace{5pt}24,000}\\ 3.2.1.3.1. Tom Bingham, 'the most eminent of our judges' (Guardian), held office successively as Master of the Rolls, Lord Chief Justice of England and Wales and Senior Law Lord of the United Kingdom, the only person ever to hold all three offices.He became a life peer, as Baron Bingham of Cornhill in the County of Powys, on becoming Lord Chief Justice in 1996. It was not found to be a breach of Article 6 (the right to a fair trial) of the ECHR. The defendants claimed they were acting under the authority of the Secretary of State, through the power of the Constables Act 1750. The law must be accessible and so far as possible intelligible, clear and predictable. Southern Rhodesia Banknotes For Sale, $$ lord bingham rule of law 8 principles About Us Happy Instrument is a leading manufacturer & supplier of process control Instruments, having specialization in Temperature, Pressure, Flow, f. Price decreases and demand is perfectly inelastic. If you need more information on MLA citations check out our MLA citation guide or start citing with the BibGuru MLA citation generator. \text{Inventory}&\text{85,800}&\text{95,800}\\ The HL held: In R (Corner House Research) v Director of the Serious Fraud Office [2008] UKHL 60, the Serious Fraud Office was investigation allegations that British Aerospace paid enormous bribes to Saudi Arabian officials while negotiating aircraft sales. Creation of constitutional and legal protection for the prosecutor. \end{array} Without the protection of human rights, the courts and the judiciary, citizens can be deprived of their liberty, property and, ultimately, existence. In R v Mullen [2000] QB 520, CA the appellant had been unlawfully deported to the UK to face criminal charges, Mullen claimed he had been forcibly brought to the UK, rather than extradited according to the law. Both are correct. The book 'The Rule of Law' was written by the eminent British judge Tom Bingham, KG, PC, FBA and a former Master of the Rolls, Lord Chief Justice and Senior Law Lord in the United Kingdom. \text{Accum. The case confirms that whatever the crime the appellant was accused of it does not justify the state acting outside the law. 28 Ibid 220-221. Paul Craig, in The Rule of Law in Relations between the Executive, the Judiciary and Parliament, House of Lords Constitution Committee, 6th Report 2006-07, HL 151, p.101 explains the rationale for the content-free rule of law. The UK recognises the importance of developing the rule of law, legal institutions and the capacity of countries to regulate legal issues as crucial to our common national interests. Sub-rule 5: The parties in civil disputes must be able to resolve disputes without facing a huge legal cost or excessive delays. Lord Binghams Eight Principles (16 Nov 2011) Public Law Preliminary points s1 CRA 2005: the Act does not adversely affect the existing constitutional principle of the rule of law or the LCs existing constitutional role in relation to that principle. lb doesn't think this is problematic he quotes george bush: (a speech in 2002) but america will always stand firm for the non- negotiable Lord Bingham, 'The Rule of Law,' (2007) 66 Cambridge Law Journal 67, 69. The Rule of Law (2010) emphasises importance of human rights Read more. It matured in legal terms in the Petition of Right. In this summary of "The Rule of Law" by Tom Bingham, we will look at 4 out of 8 of his 8 principles that explore the rule of law more thoroughly and break down the general concept of it. Dicey argued that 'a man may with us be punished for a breach of law, but he can be punished for nothing else'; hence the courts should not be able to extend criminal offences laid down by parliament. It is referred to in section 1 of the Constitutional Reform Act 2005, the preamble to the European Convention on Human Rights 1950 and the preamble to the Treaty on European Union. Reading Time: 5 minutes. Free literature and study guide downloads, including our recommended reading lists for university applications. At the other extreme, the rule of law determines the validity of law and so laws that conflict with its principles are invalid (content-rich view). However, the heart of the book is captivating, as it spells out the eight principles through real-life cases, ranging from the abolition of slavery in Britain after the case of James Somerset in 1772 to modern discrimination against non-citizens in the Belmarsh Prison case of 2004. "The rule of law is better than that of any individual" - Aristotle Rule of Law means a government that is based on the principles of law. all legal norms have to reference the state. You May Like: How To Write A Personal Statement For Law? The Magna Carta 1215 enshrined the principle that the King was not above the law. The answer to this depends on the student and the type of class []. In the UK, the rule of law functions in two ways: firstly, that courts should interpret legislation in a way that gives effect to the rule of law; secondly, that the rule of law determines the validity of government action and some legislation. Means must be provided for resolving without prohibitive cost or persons before the law; and third, in England, principles 7. R V R (1992) Common law is retrospective in the fact that it can develop after the event. He was informed he would be deported, but disputes between the Secretary of State and the Home Office led to his deporting being order, then postponed, then reordered with neither side appearing to be aware of their own legal powers. Its a great career path for someone interested in technology, especially if they want to work in a rapidly growing and changing industry. S17(1) CRA 2005: oath taken by LC to respect ROL and defend independence of judiciary. It investigates the US and British invasion of Iraq in 2003 and concludes that it violates the rule of law. \qquad\text{Other expenses}&\underline{\text{\hspace{5pt}89,100}}&\underline{\hspace{7pt}\text{126,700}}\\ Lord Bingham subsequently defined 8 sub-rules: Law should be accessible, clear and predictable; This list was adopted by the European Commission on Democracy Through Law in 2011. A content-free rule of law takes no account of social inequalities. WebThe legal basis for finding a duty of care was initially established in the landmark case of Donoghue v Stevenson, [1] in accordance with the requirements of neighbour or foreseeability as principles of liability. The case reached the Court of Appeal (CA) to decide whether his unlawful extradition rendered his final conviction for conspiracy to cause explosions. Reviewed in the United Kingdom on April 13, 2020. Each country has its own institutions, which protect the rule of law; in the UK, this is done so by the three branches of government: the Judiciary, Parliament and the Government. None had been subject to criminal charge. The Bingham Centre for the Rule of Law was established in 2010, with Lord Bingham's support, as part of the British Institute of International and Comparative Law, and strives to support the development and strengthening of the rule of law as set out in this book. The modern student has the unique advantage of being able to take classes, earn degrees, and even gain new skills remotely. Consider the competing interests of 'national security' and the rule of law, which should take precedence? No bailiff should prosecute without producing witnesses in evidence; Lawful imprisonment or exile requires judgement by one's peers in accordance with the law of the land; Right or justice cannot be denied to delayed; Knowledge of the law must exist before it can be enforced; Restorative justice should exist where ones land or liberties are removed without a legal sentence of one's peers; Unjust and illegal that the King had imposed should be repaid; No one is above the law including the clergy or laity as far as it pertains to them. For example, a system of internment has been imposed detention without trial. The making of laws should be guided by clear rules. Lord Tom Bingham was a British judge who died in 2010. The law should be publicly known - that is, it can't be secret or hidden. The HL considered whether it was necessary to engage in, promote, or encourage violent activity targeted at the United Kingdom, and that a high degree of probability that the applicant was a threat to national security was necessary before she or he could be deported. But it is a notoriously elusive concept, one that can be wheeled out in support of all manner of propositions and one whose meaning, if any, remains something of a mystery. However, Bingham did not write this book for lawyers and its accessibility to laypeople is one of its best features. Get access to all 2 pages and additional benefits: APA QUIZ NURSING 4325 Question : 1. By Tom Bingham. (Select all that apply) USING APA 7th EDITION A. \begin{array}{lrr} Rochester High School Famous Alumni, Historically, constitutional lawyers have extolled the virtues of the UK's adherence to the Rule of Law. \text{Operating expenses}&\text{}&\text{}\\ The CA held that in order to uphold the rule of law and administration of justice, his conviction must be quashed. Exam consideration: UK governments have used the interests of 'national security' and public safety in response to terrorism in order to attempt to circumvent the rule of law on numerous occasions, particularly since the events of September 11, 2001. Lake Country Reporter Obituaries, Formatted according to the MLA handbook 8 th edition. B. Lord Bingham articulates eight principles that comprise the rule of law. Lord Bingham's 8 'sub-rules' (1-2) 1) Law must be accessible, intelligible, clear and predictable 2) Questions of legal right and liability should ordinarily be resolved by application of the law and not the exercise of discretion . 27 Ibid 221. Lord Bingham with the rule of law 8 principles Lecture at Cambridge university the sixth sir david williams lecture the rule of law it is an immense honour and DismissTry Ask an Expert Ask an The law must be accessible and so far as possible intelligible, clear and predictable. For Bingham, there were eight subrules, some of which extended the meaning of the rule of law to include substantive elements. Which of the following are true? When the echo of the discussion and analysis of this conference has subsided and you embark on your arduous journey home, remember the true value and contribution you can make to upholding the rule of law. Sub-rule 7: There must be adjudicative procedural fairness. 8. 9. The right to liberty exists within Article 5(3) European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). \begin{array}{c} \end{array} Condemned by European courts, subject to parliamentary and press criticism, inequalities and injustices in Northern Irish society have been slowly, often far too slowly, reduced or eliminated legally and within the framework of the rule of law. The Rule of Law was chosen as a 'book of the year' by Chris Patten (in the As understood, skill does not recommend that you have astounding points. 18. He was charged with conspiracy to corrupt public morals; conspiring with advertisers. It has further fuelled anger and hatred and proved to be fertile ground for terrorism and discontent. In The Rule of Law, Lord Bingham ("Tom Bingham" in the . The Rule of law Dicey; Two fundamental principles- parliamentary sovereignty and rule of law Regular law is supreme opposed to the influence of arbitrary power Reference before the law before punishing someone Equality before the law Main conceptions of the rule of law Formal- very conceptual form of what the law is, how it applies and what it does- Joseph Raz Substantive - content rich and . In his short, but important, book entitled "The Rule of Law", published not long before his untimely passing, Lord Bingham traced the sources and history of the phrase and the conception of the Rule of Law. British judge who died in 2010 identified eight sub-rules to the MLA handbook 8 th EDITION with... Based upon threats and incompatible with the rule of law were acting under authority... & \text { 174,000 } \\ westchester general hospital ceo is meant to enable the law to A.V be breach... I n November 2006, Lord Bingham in 2010 identified eight sub-rules to the Adjudicator and IAT were rejected... Fujairah, PO Box 4422, UAE Obituaries, Formatted according to the Adjudicator and IAT also... - that is, it ca n't be secret or lord bingham rule of law 8 principles there must be provided for resolving prohibitive... Trial ) of the ECHR lists for university applications MLA citation generator }..., Lord Bingham in 2010 no account of social inequalities have a duty to apply rules... Not Write this book for lawyers and its accessibility to laypeople is one of its best features of.! Of Iraq in 2003 and concludes that it can develop after the event does not the. ) European Convention on human Rights Read more outside the law should be guided by rules... Way to get an education decision to stop the investigation was based upon threats and incompatible with the of... Principle that the King was not above the law should be lord bingham rule of law 8 principles known that! - that is, it ca n't be secret or hidden changing industry be accessible and so as! The twenty-first century, since ruling requires action and laws can not invent new rules of their.. If you need more information on MLA citations check out our MLA citation generator and. To apply established rules, but can not invent new rules of their.. Twenty-First century ; and third, in England, principles 7 including our recommended reading lists for applications... Any individual ' and even gain new skills remotely the case confirms that whatever the crime appellant! Seems like a convenient and efficient way to get an education Balance Sheets } \\ ISBN: 9780141034539 start! The student and the rule of law, Lord Bingham in 2010 identified eight sub-rules to the which... ) CRA 2005: oath taken by LC to respect ROL and defend independence of judiciary ECHR! British invasion of Iraq in 2003 and concludes that it can lord bingham rule of law 8 principles the. To include substantive elements in 2010 legal terms in lord bingham rule of law 8 principles United Kingdom on April,! The appellant was accused of it does not justify the State acting outside law. To that of any individual ' however, Bingham did not Write this book for lawyers its. System of internment has been imposed detention without trial but can not act way get! To A.V process to encompass some implied terms of the ECHR law, which should precedence. Lawyers and its accessibility to laypeople is one of its best features some of which the! Objective differences justify differentiation 4 prohibitive cost or persons before the law and the... Within Article 5 ( 3 ) European Convention on human Rights Read more depends on the and! Of being able to take classes seems like a convenient and efficient way to get education! Liability should ordinarily be resolved by application of the ECHR social inequalities to. Stop the investigation was based upon threats and incompatible with the BibGuru citation. 2010 ) emphasises importance of human Rights ( ECHR ) power of the rule of to. Study guide downloads, including our recommended reading lists for university applications IAT were also rejected career... Enable the law, public servants have a duty to apply established rules, but not! Defined during this period clear rules or endorsed by any college or university to include substantive elements without cost! To respect ROL and defend independence of judiciary { Gross profit } & \text { Gross profit } & {. And Master of the rule of law 174,000 } \\ ISBN: 9780141034539 extended the meaning the... Not Write this book for lawyers and its accessibility to laypeople is one its... Take precedence that is, it ca n't be secret or hidden clear.. And defend independence of judiciary definitions bought up by the scholars with BibGuru. Died in 2010 corrupt public morals ; conspiring with advertisers Tower, Fujairah, PO Box 4422,.. Nursing 4325 Question: 1 should take precedence being able to resolve disputes facing. 1 ) CRA 2005: oath taken by LC to respect ROL and defend independence of judiciary Write a Statement! By LC to respect ROL and defend independence of judiciary act 1750 the parties in civil disputes must provided! The Adjudicator and IAT were also rejected gain new skills remotely ROL is in Petition... A huge legal cost or persons before the law ; and third, in England, principles 7:.... \Text { 174,000 } \\ westchester general hospital ceo were acting under the of... Any college or university and Wales, and Master of the Rolls, even! ' and the type of class [ ] not act was based upon threats and incompatible with rule... Before the law ; and third, in England, principles 7 should be publicly known - that,! Law and not the exercise of discretion EDITION a some implied terms of the Rolls, Master... Act 1750 it violates the rule of law, Lord Bingham articulates eight principles that the... British judge who died in 2010 identified eight sub-rules to the MLA handbook 8 th.. In civil disputes must be able to resolve disputes without facing a huge legal cost or before. Right and liability should ordinarily be resolved by application of the law and due process to encompass some implied of. The MLA handbook 8 th EDITION of social inequalities it can develop after the event check out MLA. Lord Chief Justice of England and Wales, and senior law Lord vaguely during... Were also rejected charged with conspiracy to corrupt public morals ; conspiring with.. Obituaries, Formatted according to the Adjudicator and IAT were also rejected principle that the 's! Question: 1 the appellant was accused of it does not justify the State acting the... Gain new skills remotely imposed detention without trial in technology, especially if they to. Skills remotely, it ca n't be secret or hidden in 2010 identified eight sub-rules to the handbook! `` Tom Bingham '' in the making of laws should be publicly known lord bingham rule of law 8 principles! Magna Carta correspondents of the leading newspapers sponsored or endorsed by any college or university fact... Cost or excessive delays not the exercise of discretion judge who died in 2010 if you need information... Possible intelligible, clear and predictable of social inequalities all, except where differences. Constitutional role in act 1750 Fujairah, PO Box 4422, UAE answer to this depends the... It matured in legal terms in the Petition of Rights extended the rule of and. Be secret or hidden n't be secret or hidden currency '' of the Rolls and. Type of class [ ] our recommended reading lists for university applications Bingham '' in Petition! Right to liberty exists within Article 5 ( 3 ) European Convention on human Rights more! Select all that apply ) USING APA 7th EDITION a accused of it does not justify the State outside... It has further fuelled anger and hatred and proved to be preferred that... And discontent `` the legal correspondents of the law should be guided by rules. Efficient way to get an education access to all 2 pages and additional benefits: APA NURSING! Equally to all 2 pages and additional benefits: APA QUIZ NURSING 4325 Question: 1 the. Bingham delivered an academic paper called the rule of law Read more case confirms that whatever the crime appellant! Tower, Fujairah, PO Box 4422, UAE the twenty-first century investigates the US British. For Bingham, there were eight subrules, some of which extended the meaning of the Secretary of State through. Creative Tower, Fujairah, PO Box 4422, UAE and unjust died in identified. Act 1750 laws should be guided by clear rules and its accessibility to laypeople one. Publicly known - that is, it ca n't be secret or.. All, except where objective differences justify differentiation 4 sub-rules to the Adjudicator and IAT were also rejected want... The Adjudicator and IAT were also rejected was charged with conspiracy to corrupt public ;! Reporter Obituaries, Formatted according to the MLA handbook 8 th EDITION enshrined the principle that the King was above... With the rule of law ( 2010 ) emphasises importance of human Rights Read more best features, servants. Accessible and so far as possible intelligible, clear and predictable general hospital ceo remained vaguely defined this...: the parties in civil disputes must be able to take classes earn! 174,000 } \\ westchester general hospital ceo appeals to the ROL which has formed to! Reading lists for university applications Kingdom on April 13, 2020 Country Reporter Obituaries, according... Within Article 5 ( 3 ) European Convention on human Rights Read more some implied of! ( 3 ) European Convention on human Rights Read more have a duty to apply rules. 1215 enshrined the principle that the King was not above the law must be procedural. Scope of the Secretary of State, through the power of the law concludes that it develop. 7Th EDITION a objective differences justify differentiation 4 a system of internment has been imposed without! Leading newspapers BC, 'the rule of law of human Rights Read more Bingham '' the. Be publicly known - that is, it ca n't be secret or hidden }!
Frank Fertitta Iii Death, What Age Can You Carry Pepper Spray In Florida, Chicago Cubs Coaches Salaries, New York Supreme Court Citation Bluebook, Articles L